| 1999 | Pokerface |
|---|---|
| 2000 | Kryptonite |
| 2001 | Greg Anthony |
| 2002 | Jon Michael |
| 2003 | Anthony Wayne |
| 2004 | Tim Rockwell |
| 2005 | Lil' Chris |
| 2006 | Kid Nickels |
| 2007 | Slim Pickens (J.R. Stone) |
| 2008 | Dan Matthews |
| 2009 | Koko Anderson |
| 2010 | Bull Bronson |
| 2011 | Greg King Jr |
| 2012 | Terry Wayne |
| 2013 | J.P. Fantastic |
| 2014 | T.J. Lightning |
| 2015 | Dale Wylde |
| 2016 | Jakob Edwinn |
| 2017 | Tornado II (Pee Wee Pitts) & El Amigo Loco (Thud Powell) |
| 2018 | Jeffro Wilson |
| 2019 | The Eternal Flame (Cody James) |
| 2020 | Mr. Mid South (David Jason Rose) |
| 2021 | James Elliott |
| 2022 | The SuperShocker |
